本文へスキップ
Kitbay
スキル

nature-reviewer

Apache-2.02026年11月19日 更新54,246GitHubスター

A skill from the nature-skills collection that gives a mock peer review of a scientific manuscript, excerpt or pre-submission summary in the style of a Nature referee, grounded only in the material supplied.

スキルの内容

A skill from the nature-skills collection that gives a mock peer review of a scientific manuscript, excerpt or pre-submission summary in the style of a Nature referee, grounded only in the material supplied. By default three reviewers work in isolation from the same frozen packet, each judging originality, importance, breadth of readership, technical soundness and readability, with major concerns kept apart from minor comments and each tied to claim and evidence locations. A separate audit checks arithmetic, metric bounds and provenance, and a synthesis marks consensus only where at least two reviewers independently raised the same point. It does not draft rebuttals, invent experiments or citations, or predict the editor's decision.

できること

  • Run three isolated mock referee reports
  • Anchor concerns to claims and evidence
  • Audit numbers for internal consistency
  • Synthesise consensus and priority issues