Skip to content
Kitbay
Skill

academic-paper-review

MITUpdated on Nov 20, 202685,536GitHub stars

A public skill from DeerFlow, ByteDance's agent framework, for writing a structured peer review of an academic paper from a link, an arXiv page or an uploaded PDF.

What the skill teaches

A public skill from DeerFlow, ByteDance's agent framework, for writing a structured peer review of an academic paper from a link, an arXiv page or an uploaded PDF. The agent records the paper's details, reads it from start to finish and lists each main claim with its evidence, then searches for related work to place it in its field. It rates the method on soundness, novelty, reproducibility, experimental design, statistical care and scale, grades the contribution on a five-step scale and adjusts its focus for empirical, theoretical, survey, systems or position papers. The review follows a fixed template with strengths, weaknesses, questions for the authors and a recommendation, and is saved as Markdown in DeerFlow's sandbox output folder.

Capabilities

  • Summarise a paper's claims and evidence
  • Place a paper among related work
  • Rate methodology on six criteria
  • Write a peer review with a recommendation