Skip to content
Kitbay
Skill

academic-paper-reviewer

CC-BY-NC-4.0Updated on Nov 19, 202657,781GitHub starsIncludes scripts

A skill from the Academic Research Skills collection that simulates peer review at an international journal.

What the skill teaches

A skill from the Academic Research Skills collection that simulates peer review at an international journal. It works out the paper's field and sets up five review seats: a reviewer judging fit for the journal, three peer reviewers and a fixed devil's advocate, each writing a separate report on fit, methods, contribution to the field, links to other disciplines and the core argument. A synthesiser combines the reports into an editorial decision letter and a revision plan. Modes cover full review, re-review after revision, quick review, a methods focus, a guided mode and calibration. Reviewers read the manuscript but never edit it, and helper scripts check the synthesis, acronyms and reference suggestions.

Capabilities

  • Simulate a five-reviewer journal review
  • Write an editorial decision letter
  • Produce a revision plan for authors
  • Re-review a revised manuscript