Skip to content
Kitbay
Skill

nature-response

Apache-2.0Updated on Nov 19, 202654,246GitHub starsIncludes scripts

A skill in the nature-skills collection for answering peer review of a scientific paper, in English or Chinese.

What the skill teaches

A skill in the nature-skills collection for answering peer review of a scientific paper, in English or Chinese. It drafts, audits or revises point-by-point reply letters, revision cover letters and marked or LaTeX revision packages. From a pasted journal email it pulls out the editor's instructions and numbers each reviewer comment, sorts them by the action needed, keeps an internal tracker, and writes a reply per reviewer that maps every claimed change to a place in the manuscript. It asks whether the decision was major or minor revision rather than guessing, never invents experiments, citations, line numbers or changes, and marks anything the author must supply. A bundled Python script checks LaTeX packages for consistency.

Capabilities

  • Split reviewer comments into numbered items
  • Draft point-by-point reply letters
  • Write a revision cover letter
  • Check a LaTeX revision package for consistency